The question of who should lead the English State Party is going to be an important one for our future success in elections, particularly with the increasing likelihood of a Snap General Election in the coming months. This is also our first real election for an English State Party chair, so whoever wins will be setting a standard for their successors, so choosing a candidate who will set good standards will be especially relevant in this regards..
To start off with, Mark Johnston isn't in the running for me at all, anything positive I could say about him is totally nullified by his work with groups within the Party that actively seek to restrict the liberty of LGBT minorities to "protect" society at large. For this reason I cannot support him.
With that out the way, to properly get into things, Chris White is no doubt a promising candidate, as he has played a key role in several structural decisions for the new model of the English Party, and his commitment to diversity is backed up by a strong track record of promoting women-only shortlists for candidates which helped lessen male dominance in our General Election slates. My only issue with this was that he did not actually explain how he would further this within the State.
His more concrete structural reforms were also not necessarily appealing to me, remodelling Local Parties around the London ones doesn't read to me like a formula for success, as our London representation is now hyper-focused around the wealthy South West region, in which the Gail's theorem is particularly true, and in areas like West Suffolk where we have rates of good education well below the national average, this form of Middle-to-Upper Class Liberalism simply wouldn't provide as effective of an organisational basis for campaigning.
Part of this problem is of course the extent to which we have institutionalised the Party Machine, we have optimised Local Politics to the point where we have lost our sense of national message, so Chris's comment in his Lib Dem Voice article that, "I know how much a win depends on the machinery behind the candidate." doesn't reassure me in this regard; wins do not come from machines, but from people, a machine may predict an easy place to win, but it does not predict the shock victories. Plus, Chris's description of Clegg as a "great communicator" in 2012 of all years, makes me feel his political judgement might not always be best.
So what is George Potter offering in comparison? Well, he has been a lot clearer on the finances for one, in his Lib Dem Voice article he is straight with the fact of the budget being £650,000 in 2022 and is clear that this should be used to diversify beyond Southwest and Southeast England through the expansion of the Regional Development Offices. George is also clear that Local Parties know what works in their areas and commits himself to "a State Party that listens to you." rather than imposing a top-down approach.
To make my biases clear here, I have worked with George in the past to oppose top-down decisions from HQ, but this is why I'm all the more convinced he won't attempt a "one size fits all" model on our Local Parties, because he has spent so much time fighting against it. This also isn't to say I don't have criticisms of his plans either, his commitment to greater accountability for spending doesn't have a particularly clear explanation of how such a thing would be structured in practice, and he is much less clear on how things will change to accommodate the new souped-up Mayors Labour is imposing on us than Chris, but overall, his message has appealed to me more, and I think will set good standards for the future.
The wonderful thing about our elections is that we get multiple votes, so while I will personally be putting George Potter for my #1 vote, I'm also giving Chris my #2! Whoever wins I hope they'll do a great job at expanding our Party for the coming Elections.

No comments:
Post a Comment